Disney’s steep streaming costs push shares to 2.5-year low

by Jacob Fuller


Shares in Walt Disney Co tumbled 12% to the lowest since March 2020 on Wednesday, as ballooning costs at the entertainment giant’s fast-growing streaming division cast a shadow on strong subscriber additions.

Disney+ has attracted millions of subscribers and will launch an ad-supported tier next month, but executives’ promise of profitability next year and forecast for operating results in the next quarter failed to impress.

The company missed analysts’ expectations for fourth-quarter earnings, after a $1.5 billion loss in its streaming division.

“Disney’s streaming results are indicative of the tightrope it is walking,” said Fred Boxa, associate director at consulting firm Arthur D. Little.

Finance chief Christine McCarthy, in a call with analysts on Tuesday, said the ad tier was not expected to meaningfully impact results until later in the financial year.

Subscriber growth in Disney+ was expected to accelerate in the second quarter, she added, a sign analysts said indicated a soft first quarter.

“As the platform aims for profitability, it’s placing some of that burden on its user base in the form of price hikes that could stall growth during a time of economic pinch,” said Mike Proulx, research director at Forrester.

A weaker-than-expected annual revenue growth forecast also dragged shares. Disney estimated a “high single-digit” percentage growth, while the Street was expecting 12%.

At least 13 brokerages cut their price targets on Disney stock.

McCarthy said streaming operating results would improve by at least $200 million in the first quarter of fiscal 2023, compared with the latest reported quarter.

“We expect that the ‘achieving profitability’ breakthrough will likely occur in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2024,” Morningstar analyst Neil Macker said.

Shares have fallen more than 35% this year, compared with a 20% drop in the S&P 500, battered by a cautious outlook for ad sales and recessionary fears.

Go woke, go broke

Also in play is Disney’s embrace of radical “woke ideology” — including Black Lives Matter campaigns and a large increase in LGBTQ programming and funding — that has turned many conservative and Christian viewers away. For example, this summer’s “Lightyear,” a spinoff of the massively popular Toy Story franchise, featured a lengthy homage to a lesbian character, her partner, and their child that included a kiss shared by the lesbian couple.

By Pixar and Disney standards, and especially those set by the Toy Story franchise, “Lightyear” was a colossal flop. Reports estimated the movie cost $200 million to make and needed to bring in about $400 million to break even after promotion and distribution costs. Worldwide, the film brought in just over $226 million. For comparison, “Toy Story 3” (2010) and “Toy Story 4” (2019) each grossed more than $1 billion worldwide.

The company also lost its special tax status in Florida after criticizing the state’s Parental Rights in Education bill.

Copyright 2022 Thomson/Reuters. Additions and edits by Jacob Fuller, FISM News.