First attempted private moon landing fails after lander crash

by mcardinal


Japan‘s ispace inc said its attempt to make the first private moon landing had failed after losing contact with its Hakuto-R Mission 1 (M1) lander when it unexpectedly accelerated and probably crashed on the lunar surface.

The startup said it was possible that as the lander approached the moon, its altitude measurement system had miscalculated the distance to the surface.

“It apparently went into a free-fall towards the surface as it was running out of fuel to fire up its thrusters,” Chief Technology Officer Ryo Ujiie told a news conference on Wednesday.

It was the second setback for commercial space development in a week after SpaceX’s Starship rocket exploded spectacularly minutes after soaring off its launch pad.

A private firm has yet to succeed with a lunar landing. Only the United States, the former Soviet Union, and China have soft-landed spacecraft on the moon, with attempts in recent years by India and a private Israeli company also ending in failure.

Ispace, which is working to deliver payloads such as rovers to the moon and sells related data, had only just listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange two weeks ago and a frenzy of excitement around its prospects had driven up its shares some seven-fold since then.

But disappointment led to a glut of sell orders on Wednesday. After being untraded all day, the stock finished down 20% in a forced closing price decided by the bourse that reflects the balance of buy and sell orders.

Japan‘s top government spokesperson Hirokazu Matsuno said while it was sad that the mission did not succeed, the country wants ispace to “keep trying” as its efforts were significant to the development of a domestic space industry.

Japan, which has set itself a goal of sending Japanese astronauts to the moon by the late 2020s, has had some recent setbacks. The national space agency last month had to destroy its new medium-lift H3 rocket upon reaching space after its second-stage engine failed to ignite. Its solid-fuel Epsilon rocket also failed after its launch in October.


Four months after launching from Cape Canaveral, Florida, on a SpaceX rocket, the M1 lander appeared set to autonomously touch down at about 1:40 a.m. Japan time, with an animation based on live telemetry data showing it coming as close as 295 feet from the lunar surface.

By the expected touchdown time, mission control had lost contact with the lander and engineers appeared anxious over the live stream as they awaited signal confirmation of its fate which never came.

The lander completed eight out of 10 mission objectives in space that will provide valuable data for the next landing attempt in 2024, Chief Executive Takeshi Hakamada said.

Roughly an hour before planned touchdown, the 2.3 meter-tall M1 began its landing phase, gradually tightening its orbit around the moon from 62 miles above the surface to roughly 15 miles, traveling at nearly 3,700 mph.

At such velocity, slowing the lander to the correct speed against the moon’s gravitational pull is like squeezing the brakes of a bicycle right at the edge of a ski-jumping slope, Ujiie has said.

The craft was aiming for a landing site at the edge of Mare Frigoris in the moon’s northern hemisphere where it would have deployed a two-wheeled, baseball-sized rover developed by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, Tomy Co Ltd and Sony Group Corp. It also planned to deploy a four-wheeled rover dubbed Rashid from the United Arab Emirates.

The lander was carrying an experimental solid-state battery made by Niterra Co Ltd among other devices to gauge their performance on the moon.

In its second mission scheduled in 2024, the M1 will carry ispace’s own rover, while from 2025, it is set to work with U.S. space lab Draper to bring NASA payloads to the moon, aiming to build a permanently staffed lunar colony by 2040.

Copyright 2023 Thomson/Reuters